This video is no longer available.
Gutterless Gutters, Desert Plan | Ask TOH
05/03/18 | 23m 43s | Rating: TV-G
Tom installs an alternative to a gutter when a traditional one does not work; Ross and Richard update Kevin on a Future House technology; Jenn heads to Phoenix to recreate the desert in a homeowner’s front yard.
Copy and Paste the Following Code to Embed this Video:
Gutterless Gutters, Desert Plan | Ask TOH
Kevin
Today on "Ask This Old House"...
Greg
There's one project in particular that I wrote in about -- a gutter problem here.
Tom
Oh, yeah. You definitely have a gutter problem. You have an outlet for a downspout. Oh, then again, no downspout. Think you've seen everything in gutters? Well, think again.
Jenn
I'm taking my cues from the desert as I design a new front yard in Phoenix. So, your yard is very flat, and what we want to do is mimic the foothills of the mountains nearby, so we're gonna create these mounds just to add some undulation to your landscape.
Ross
And, after living with technology from Future House for a year, I'll show you what we learned.
Richard
This is a typical spike right here just for the coffeemaker.
Kevin
Hi, there. I'm Kevin O'Connor, And welcome back to "Ask This Old House," where we love getting your questions about your houses, so make sure you keep your letters and your e-mails coming. The guys are standing by. Hey,
Roger. Roger
Hey, Kev. You seen Jenn?
Kevin
Yeah, yeah. She's doing a story on actually landscaping in a desert, so she's actually going to the desert. She's on a flight right now to Arizona.
Roger
Really?
Kevin
Oh, yeah.
Roger
I wanted to warn her about the jumping cactus.
Kevin
About the what?
Roger
Jumping cactus.
Kevin
Come on. The what?
Roger
It's a form of cactus that is attracted to water, which, who has a lot of water in their bodies?
We do. Roger
Okay. Has little tendrils on it that pierce the skin and go into your skin and lock in place.
Kevin
Are you telling me this thing, like, when you're walking by, just reaches out and grabs you?
Roger
It can move and grab you.
Kevin
What do you do then?
Roger
Well, you got to get it off you, and you don't want to take it off with your hands because, if you go to put it like this, it's gonna spread.
Kevin
And then you're gonna be attached to your hands, which is gonna be attached to your thigh.
Well... Roger
So...
Kevin
...Jenn, she's going. What?
Roger
There you go.
No way. Use this. Roger
Yep. As soon as you see it, grab it and pull it off.
Kevin
Whew. All right. Well, you know what? She's a professional, so I'm gonna guess that Jenn already knows about this. So she should be all right. She's never gonna get this through TSA, though.
Laughs
Roger
Tom
Hey,
Greg. Greg
Hey, Tommy. How you doing?
Tom
Nice to see you. How are you?
Greg
You too.
Thanks for coming. Tom
I like your house.
Thank you. Tom
Small house, but very nice.
Greg
Yeah. Yeah. So, my wife and I have been here about a year now. We've been trying to knock off a few little projects and everything, but there's one project in particular that I wrote in about -- our gutter problem here.
Tom
Oh, yeah. You definitely have a gutter problem. There's no end caps here. Bracket's falling off. The spikes are coming out. This joint definitely looks like it will leak.
Laughs
Tom
Oh, and there's no brackets on that gutter. Well, you have an outlet for a downspout. Oh, then again, no downspout.
Greg
Yeah. So, this is a project that I really wanted to tackle myself, the downspout being one of the biggest problems, though. The water coming down, pooling here. I'm concerned about it getting in the basement. So I said, "Why don't we switch it, put the downspout in the driveway?" But then, you know, the winter, the ice...
Tom
Yeah. You don't want that either.
Greg
So I'm really hoping you might have some alternative
for me. Tom
Well, you know, a lot of people want to take the gutters off. They don't want to deal with them. They think they're a problem. They got to clean them and everything else. But they're important to protect the house. Water coming off the roof gets into the gutter, and then it's dispersed away from the building, like downspout. If you take that gutter off, the water coming off the roof hits the ground, splashes back, hits the siding. It could rot the siding and even your sill. But in this situation, you know what? I have an idea that we can put something up here that will take the water off the roof, hit that, and then disperse it so you're not getting splash back onto it.
All right. Tom
All right? Want me to get some tools?
Greg
Let's do it.
Tom
And we can get started. All right, Greg. You ever see anything like this before?
Never. Tom
Well, I'm gonna call this
a gutterless gutter. Greg
A gutterless gutter?
All right. Tom
All right? It's actually a louver, and you can see it right here, and it will mount to the fascia board on these brackets right here. Now, as the water runs off the roof like a waterfall, it'll splash onto the louver. Because of the angle of the louver, it takes that water that's coming down and turns it into raindrops and pushes it away from the building.
Okay. Tom
Okay? So, first thing we need to do is remove your old gutter and mount the brackets.
Let's do it. Tom
Okay. Got these spikes. These are called spikes and ferrules, which is just a long spike that goes through a tube. We're gonna try to work those out. Actually used drywall screws, and that's a no-no. You shouldn't be using that. Okay. Before we install the louvers, I want to correct a problem that I see done wrong a lot. See this piece of metal right here? This is called a drip edge, and it's designed to break the surface tension from the water that falls off the roof.
Greg
So, what exactly is surface tension?
Tom
Well, it's like adhesion, so a lot of people think that, when the water comes off the roof, it'll fall straight down. Well, a lot of it does, but some of it actually sticks to the shingle, and it will run up and hit the drip edge and then run down. If there's nothing to stop it, it will continue to stick to the fascia board, run under, run down on the fascia board here, rotting the siding and the fascia board. So what I want to do is create a gap or a space right here at the lower edge of the drip edge so if the water comes down and around, it will fall down straight. So all I need to do is bend this out about 1/4 to 1/2 inch all the way down the roof. Could of last things I want to do -- There's no finished trim piece here, so I want to fill that gap right there with some caulking. And I also want to just touch up these holes where the spikes and ferrules were, hopefully stopping some water from getting behind. All right. We're gonna start mounting the brackets to the fascia board. We're gonna come in 10 inches from the end, 30 inches to the center, and another 20 inches for the other end. Now, the manufacturer wants the bracket mounted to the fascia board as far down as you can get it. They want a minimum of 4 inches from here, the top of the louver, to the bottom of the edge of the roof. They also want it to be 1 1/2 to 2 inches from the fascia board to the leading edge of the roof so when the water falls off, it'll splash onto the louver. Okay? Ready to screw that into place.
Drill whirring
Tom
Okay. Now we'll see if we can get the louver in. And then we just push this back in, clip it. Okay. That in. And then... that one.
Greg
That's it?
Tom
That's it. Three more to go, and we're done.
Drill whirring
Tom
Good. Push hard. All right. Greg, everything's in, and it feels like we're gonna get some rain, but I don't want to wait for the rain, so let's try it out. Now we'll spray some water up on the roof, but this could be like a heavy rain, so my guess is that it's gonna run over and past it. It's when it slows down. We'll see what happens when it hits the louver. See? It's stopping, hitting the louver, and it's pushing it right out. That's pretty cool.
Greg
That's great.
Working good. Greg
Listen. Thank you so much for your help.
I really appreciate it. Tom
My pleasure.
Kevin
Boy, I don't know, Tommy. I mean, I love the fact that it kicks the water away from the side wall, but all these years, we talk about catching the water and moving it away from the house, and it's all just dropping right next to that garage.
Tom
Well, it was a pretty tight spot, and it had good drainage down there, and you're right -- Water should be kept away from the foundation. So when the water drops down, you can always put a French drain aboveground in there and a pipe to get the water away.
Kevin
So, on a big house, we would probably have a drainage system down on the ground?
I would say so. Yes. Kevin
Okay.
Tom
All right? So, the key is that the manufacturer wants to make sure that the water comes off the roof and hits the center of the louver or as close to the louver as possible.
Kevin
So they're worried about the distance between the edge of the roof and the edge of this fascia right here?
Tom
Exactly right, and that distance has to be no more than 2 and no less than 1 1/2 inch.
Kevin
Right.
Tom
So if your roof is closer to the fascia board, they make an extender right here that you could screw on the fascia board, and that will kick the edge out so that, when the water falls, it falls down and then to the center louver.
Kevin
They're also particular about dimension from here down to the top of this louver, right? It's got to be down a certain height. What if you don't have enough fascia to affix it to?
Tom
Well, if you have a narrow fascia board, they make a bracket right here that can be screwed to the bottom of the fascia board, and you can adjust it down as needed. Again, they want it further down. The better it is, it comes off the roof, the water splashes in there, and then disperses.
Kevin
I know you're always trying to protect against the effects of surface tension, and the drip edge, I mean, you hate the fact that it's touching the fascia. That's just a pet peeve of yours.
Tom
Because the water is the enemy. It'll come down off the roof. It'll stick to the fascia board as it falls if there's not a space here. I usually like that gap to be at least the thickness of my fingers so when the water comes down, it won't stick to the fascia board, rotting it.
Kevin
And your fingers are pretty thick.
Yeah. Kevin
So, you built this one, and so this is the distance that you like to see. And, here, you've got it not just on the fascia, but you've got it going up the rake, as well.
Tom
Wherever there's a transition from the surface, it should always be a space -- like a windowsill, for example. An angled windowsill, the rain comes down on the windowsill, hits the -- comes off, hits the leading edge,
and it wants to go back up. Kevin
Right.
Tom
If you look under that windowsill,
there's usually a dado. Kevin
Yeah.
Tom
And that dado is a groove that, when the water comes down, it hits that groove. It drops it away. It drops away.
Kevin
Well, all right. Good information as always.
Thank you. Tom
Yep.
Kevin
Hey,
Ross. Ross
Hey, Kevin.
Kevin
Playing with your energy monitor there?
Ross
Yeah. We looked at this technology last year on Future House. It's an energy monitor that connects to the two hot leads on your home's electrical panel and then transmits data about your power consumption via Wi-Fi. It's giving you a snapshot of what the house is using for electricity. It's also giving you device by device. It's actually learning the signatures of the house. And my brother and I bought one for our Father's Day.
Kevin
Oh, lucky him, huh?
Richard
So finally a Father's Day gift that wasn't a hand tool or a tie.
Kevin
I got my dad a nice bottle of scotch.
Ross
You don't like the ties?
Kevin
But this is what happens when you come from a family of plumbers.
Richard
So, I have a house that was built to all the energy standards, the highest energy standards in 2004. We put this thing in. I turn on the switch on the recess cans over the kitchen island, and we watch this thing spike by like 900 watts.
Kevin
Wow.
Richard
So, these were recessed halogen lights. I thought they were efficient. They aren't. So now what that does is, it, all of a sudden, made me start thinking about, "Boy, I'm gonna leave those lights off and..."
Kevin
Maybe screw in some L.E.D.s, 'cause now those are efficient. You can use those.
Ross
And one of the other things was with the coffeemaker. You know, you think -- You know, it's a pod style. You think it's actually gonna be, you know, only on when you're using it, but in this case, it's actually cycling.
We could see it on and off... Kevin
Wait a second.
Ross
...where you could see a spike on, a spike off.
Kevin
You put the pod in. You press brew, and it comes on.
Richard
Right, but it's got a little heating element that keeps that little reservoir... There's an electric element that keeps it on and off all day long, so when I leave, I make sure I turn that blue button off so I'm not doing it. This is a typical spike right here just for the coffeemaker.
Kevin
So, I mean, this is the idea, right? Without the information, you can't fix the problem
or change the behavior. Richard
Right.
Kevin
So, now this is starting to change your behavior. I remember, though, the thing that got you excited was the ability to sort of foreshadow problems, right? You guys were seeing... Was it a furnace that was cycling on and off? And you were afraid it was gonna break down?
Ross
So, we saw a furnace that took three ignition cycles to start when it should only take one. And so that can be indicative of a problem. You know, what was cool about this was the refrigerator, right? We saw the refrigerator was on all the time. It was drawing 1,300 watts when it was cycling.
Kevin
Going to the fridge?
Richard
No. The compressor just would not shut off. Well, we found out, that the filter on the front that pulls all the air in was completely clogged. If no air goes in, it's not gonna take the heat away from the refrigerator, and the compressor will just stay on, on, on and won't cool the box.
Kevin
So, now you've got the information. You saw the problem. Do you foresee a day when nerds like you don't have to buy it and install it?
Richard
Nerds?
Kevin
No. I mean, I say it in a loving way, but where it actually just is built into the technology?
Ross
Yeah. I see a day in the future where that type of device will be installed standard in any electrical panel. And what's great about that is that it's gonna send you a text message or an e-mail, saying, "Your refrigerator is using 35% more electricity this month than it did last month." Right? Something might be up.
Richard
If, and when, that happens, it's standard, then, and only then, will we actually change behaviors and reduce electricity consumption.
Kevin
Which would be a good day... although you'd be left with one problem, and that's, what do you do for Father's Day?
Back to the ties. Richard
I'll take the scotch.
Kevin
Scotch would be nice.
Jenn
My favorite landscape designs are those that mimic nature. To get inspired, sometimes you just got to get out there and take a hike. South Mountain Park is a 16,000-acre natural preserve just south of downtown Phoenix, and I've come here to check out the natural, undisturbed desert. That is so cool. Nothing's really clumped together. There's no patterns. It's almost like a mulch, but it's all just tiny pieces that have just broken up over time. So many people think the desert's just flat. This is a very hilly terrain. The challenge for any designer is that you cannot replicate nature exactly in a suburban lot. What I like to do is take cues from the natural world and try to integrate them into my designs. Here in Phoenix, I'm working with Rod Pappas, who's a local landscape contractor, to do just that. So, Rod, we have a blank canvas here. Is this typical of the landscape in Phoenix?
Rod
Yes, it is. It's very typical of somebody's front yard who may have had turf at one time, covered it up with some sort of weed barrier, put granite down, and called it a day.
Jenn
Right. Well, the only thing I see here is this honeysuckle.
Rod
It's blocking the window. It's causing some security issues. We're gonna do away with it.
Jenn
All right. We could do that.
Hi. Jenn
Hi, Shoshana.
Morning. Jenn
Nice to see you.
Good morning. Hi. Rod
Hello.
Jenn
So, when you... So, when we all spoke on the phone, we talked about wheelchair access for your mother, right?
Shoshana
Right, 'cause my biggest concern is always to get my mother out and get her to the street.
Rod
Right, right. Once we learned about that, we decided that it'd be best if we built a natural-looking walkway out of pavers, so we're gonna come off of this sidewalk here, come out here a ways, and, about middle of the yard, start curving in and then back out again, and eventually meet up with the sidewalk here. It's gonna be easy now for them to roll either a gurney or a wheelchair or whatever they want back and forth. It will be plenty wide for accessibility.
Jenn
Which is very, very important.
Shoshana
Yeah.
Jenn
So, another thing in the plan -- We are gonna use native plants, try to take cues from nature what's gonna grow successfully here. And another thing we're going to incorporate are boulders, which are indigenous to this area. So -- But we first have to get started and take that honeysuckle out.
Rod
Okay. I'm going to scrape some of this rock off, and you guys can dig the dirt underneath, okay, once we get some of this granite scraped away.
All right. Jenn
Yes!
Rod
Okay. We've got a rough outline started here for our walkway. It's gonna be about 3 feet wide, so we're gonna dig down about 3 or 4 inches, clear off that granite all the way, and put it to the side for future use.
Jenn
So, your yard is very flat, and what we want to do is mimic the foothills of the mountains nearby, so we're gonna create these mounds that are about 4 feet wide by about 8 feet long, 6 or 8 inches high, just to add some undulation to your landscape.
Rod
Before we place the boulders, we're gonna dig out an indentation about the size of the boulder, go down about 3 or 4 inches so it looks like the boulder's been sitting there for about 1,000 years.
Jenn
I'm gonna dump it. Ready?
Rod
Yeah.
Jenn
Okay. So, now we have three mounds throughout the property, and boulders have been placed. We've also staged all the plants, and we'd like to stage the plants so you have the ability to adjust them or move them around or tweak them... unless you absolutely love it. What do you think?
Shoshana
I'm in love with it.
Jenn
Yes!
Rod
It's amazing how much color you can get from desert plants out here. Like, this red yucca right here -- This is gonna bloom like eight months out of the year, you'll have multiple stalks out of here, and it goes with your mailbox.
Jenn
Love that touch. That's awesome. Over here, we have some lantana on the ground. It's a perennial, and it's gonna cover this ground with this beautiful yellow flower for most of the year.
Shoshana
Oh, it's wonderful.
Jenn
Yeah. One plant goes a long, long way.
Rod
Hey, guys, look over here. A bougainvillea. Have you ever seen one of these before?
Jenn
Well, I grew up in Florida, so I see them all the time crawling over walls.
Rod
Uh-huh. Well, this one's not gonna do that 'cause it stays close to the ground. It's a compact variety, only gets about 2 or 3 feet tall, and that's as big as it gets.
Jenn
So just like a mound on the ground?
Rod
Just like a ground-cover mound, yeah.
Jenn
And that color is amazing.
Shoshana
Oh,
that's neat. Rod
Yeah, it is. And this is our anchor tree of the whole design, the Chilean mesquite. This is gonna be the biggest plant eventually on this property. It's thornless, as you can see, has a very airy, delicate-type leaf to it, and you've got a few of them in the neighborhood, don't you?
Shoshana
Actually, these are one of my favorite trees because, as the years go on, the bark actually starts to turn.
Rod
Got some barrel cactus over here. These are called golden barrels. They do very well with little water. The color in these is the thorns and the crown. You very rarely see any blossoms on these. But be careful handling those. They will bite.
Jenn
I'm gonna let you plant these.
Okay. Jenn
Okay?
Rod
Couple more lantana. Then we have some agave agustinas. And they will actually multiply and shoot out additional pups, what we call them, from the sides.
Mm-hmm. Rod
After about 7, 8 years, they'll send up a stalk that blooms a nice bright yellow.
Jenn
Yeah.
Rod
And that's the end of their lifetime. So...
Jenn
And then the plant will die?
Rod
That's right. The plant will die, but it leaves behind a family of young ones that will continue to grow.
Jenn
All right. Well, let's get these in the ground.
Rod
We're cutting away the plastic on the outside here because we want to still keep the rest of it intact to serve as a weed barrier. When we're digging this hole for the plant here, we want to keep the hole about twice as big as the original container. The key to planting a cactus is to protect your hands from all those thorns, and I have a piece of cardboard that I'm gonna wrap around it while I try and work it free of the container.
Jenn
Nice. Looks pretty good, yeah?
Rod
Yep, pretty good. So, we're ready to start with the walkway, and what we did first to prepare for it was to excavate down about 4 inches. We backfilled it with a 1/4 minus granite, which is 1/4 inch smaller. We leveled it, and then we went over it with a plate compactor.
Jenn
All right. So, here are our pavers. These are all modular, but we picked the color to have earth tones in it.
Shoshana
I like the color, but are we gonna have any concern with my mom in the wheelchair getting through?
Rod
No. They're gonna fit together really close. There's not gonna be any mortar joints, so we're talking about maybe 1/16 of an inch
in between those joints. Jenn
They're gonna be tight.
Shoshana
Real tight?
Okay. Jenn
Yeah. So there's not gonna be any divots
that you're gonna fall into. Shoshana
Okay. This is going pretty fast.
Jenn
Well, these are modular bricks, and as long as you have the proper base that we put down, it's gonna fly.
Shoshana
Oh, I love these colors.
Jenn
I know. You really can tell the color scheme when it's all laid out. That's why, if you're ever getting samples for a job, get at least five so you could really get a sense of what the true palette is.
Rod
Okay. Jenn, we're gonna use this piece of pipe, measuring the distance from that border there to the edge of this pipe.
All right. Rod
And after we get that, I'm gonna put this brick on there to hold it in place. And now we're ready to move on to the next spot. Okay. We're gonna trace this line of PVC with a pencil on top of the brick and then come back with a wet saw and cut it after we remove the pipe. Okay, Shoshana, the landscaping's all in. We watered it in really good with a hose, soaked it down. You'll probably need to give it some supplemental water for the first six months. After that, you can pretty much back off and let nature run its course with it.
Shoshana
All right. I can do that.
Jenn
And I just want to say, Rod, I love this landscape. We have this walkway. It's a concrete paver, not a natural material, but the color blends so perfectly with all the stone that we put in and then the boulders and the mounds. This site this morning was flat, and now just having that undulation in the landscape and then accenting it with all the different plants and textures and colors that are gonna come out, it really, really works well.
Shoshana
This entire experience has been amazing. The yard looks incredible. Thank you both for all your help.
Jenn
Thanks for having us in Phoenix.
Rod
You're welcome.
Kevin
Next time on "Ask This Old House"...
Mauro
Paint is much easier to put on than take it off. I'm heading to Sacramento to show you how to do it safely and correctly.
Woman
Wow. That looks great.
Jenn
And I'll show you the right way to hook up your...
Richard
No, no, no, no, no. I'll do this tease. I'll show the right way to connect water to a refrigerator with an ice maker.
Laughs
Richard
Search Episodes
Donate to sign up. Activate and sign in to Passport. It's that easy to help PBS Wisconsin serve your community through media that educates, inspires, and entertains.
Make your membership gift today
Only for new users: Activate Passport using your code or email address
Already a member?
Look up my account
Need some help? Go to FAQ or visit PBS Passport Help
Need help accessing PBS Wisconsin anywhere?
Online Access | Platform & Device Access | Cable or Satellite Access | Over-The-Air Access
Visit Access Guide
Need help accessing PBS Wisconsin anywhere?
Visit Our
Live TV Access Guide
Online AccessPlatform & Device Access
Cable or Satellite Access
Over-The-Air Access
Visit Access Guide
Passport

Follow Us