Antiques Roadshow

GUEST

I collected fishing tackle for a number of years.

APPRAISER

Okay.

GUEST

And kind of progressed into the ice fishing decoys. I just love the folk art form of them.

APPRAISER

Right. So where did you find the decoy, actually?

GUEST

The large one was actually purchased at an auction by my wife, and then given to me for Christmas.

APPRAISER

Okay.

GUEST

And the smaller ones, one was a gift from my mother, and the other one I picked up at a tag sale in Connecticut, actually.

APPRAISER

First of all, let me say there's a whole group of people that collect fish decoys. And these were used, as you know, for ice fishing. And basically, the fishermen would go out and drill the large hole, of course, with a shack above it, usually, if it was bad weather, and drill some smaller holes around that big hole and let these decoys down through the ice, and they would just dangle there in the water. And then fish would come up. This is probably a pike, I'd guess, would you say?

GUEST

Or maybe a muskie.

APPRAISER

Or maybe a muskie. A big, big fish. Really mean looking teeth, nice brass tack. But to a big fish coming along, a muskie or a pike, he might say, "Hey, it looks pretty safe over there." You know, "Look at that-- that fish is hanging out, and so I can, too." It's one of the biggest folk art decoys that I've seen. It has its original paint, these wonderful spots, the original tin. And you can see these three holes, and that's what they, of course, hung it from. It's just a really nice, powerful decoy, okay? The other two that you brought in are nice small examples. And these would have been probably simulating either trout or some kind of a...wouldn't you say... A perch, maybe? This looks like a perch here. And they have nice original paint with the dots and the green. And generally to collectors, the ones that bring them more money are ones that are curved or that have really nice paint, I think, like this, this nice striping. So these are fun. These would be great Christmas tree ornaments. Do you use them at Christmas?

GUEST

I used to have them hanging all around the house.

APPRAISER

Did you really?

GUEST

Yeah.

APPRAISER

This one, probably worth around $250 to $300, this one about the same. And this, this would be worth upwards of about $2,000 retail.

GUEST

Wow. My wife will be very pleased.

APPRAISER

What did she pay for it?

GUEST

$100.

APPRAISER

She did a great job.

GUEST

I'm very happy.