Education|Classroom Media|Resources|History|Food & Travel
Serving up curiosity through Carson Gulley’s fudge bottom pie
I recently found myself panicking about pie – Carson Gulley’s fudge bottom pie.
Education|Classroom Media|Resources|History|Food & Travel
I recently found myself panicking about pie – Carson Gulley’s fudge bottom pie.
I recently found myself panicking about pie – Carson Gulley’s fudge bottom pie.
Gulley was a chef, activist, educator and media pioneer in Wisconsin. His story is the latest addition to “Wisconsin Biographies,” an educational resource collection from PBS Wisconsin Education featuring historical images, educator guides and videos.

“Carson Gulley: A Recipe for Change” follows Gulley’s life from rural Arkansas to Madison, Wisconsin. He and his wife, Beatrice, became two of the nation’s first Black cooking celebrities. The couple also faced housing discrimination and fought for years for the right to own a house.
While I made plans to share the resource with audiences, Gulley’s fudge bottom pie caught my attention.
The University of Wisconsin-Madison has been serving fudge bottom pie for decades, dating back to Gulley’s time as chef for UW Housing. If you own a copy of his 1956 cookbook, “Seasoning Secrets and Favorite Recipes of Carson Gulley,” you can find the recipe on page 106, right after Rhubarb Custard Pie. Physical copies are hard to find, so I turned to PBS Wisconsin archivist Clara Wolfe, who pointed me to a digitized copy from UW-Madison Archives.

Carson Gulley Cookbook Collection, “Seasoning Secrets and Favorite Recipes of Carson Gulley” (1956). Photo courtesy of UW–Madison Archives.
I decided to try making the vintage recipe and write about the experience.
When I shared the idea with colleagues, education producer David Boffa suggested taking the opportunity to make a video out of it, too. “Why not?” I thought. It was about time that two-week drama class I took in third grade finally paid off.
On the day we were scheduled to bake and film, I was up early thinking about Gulley. I wondered if there was footage online of the Gulleys’ cooking show, “What’s Cookin.’” The show ran from 1953-1962 on WMTV in Madison. Unfortunately, no footage remains. (If you happen to find a box of “What’s Cookin’” reels in your great-aunt’s attic, let me know.)

Gulley and his wife, Beatrice, filming at WMTV in Madison, Wisconsin. “Chef Carson Gulley’s Cooking Show” (Image W014DKS). Photo courtesy of the Wisconsin Historical Society.
Instead, I found a 2022 interview segment from “The Larry Meiller Show” featuring Scott Seyforth, Assistant Director for Residence Education at UW-Madison, who had researched and written an article for the Wisconsin Magazine of History called “The Life and Times of Carson Gulley.”
When the subject of fudge bottom pie came up, Seyforth quickly pointed out there is no record that Gulley thought the pie was notable. (The recipe he seems to have been most proud of? Baked beans.) Regardless of which menu item the university chose as a tribute to Gulley, it wouldn’t be able to fully capture his story, accomplishments or the historical context around them.
Cue my panic.
I had known the pie wasn’t the point of the “Wisconsin Biographies” story. It’s not even mentioned in the video. “Why did I choose it anyway?” I asked myself. But I didn’t have time to pivot to something else, so I packed up the pie ingredients and dashed out the door to meet up with Boffa.

“Carson Gulley With Pies” (Image W012EKC). Photo courtesy of the Wisconsin State Journal and the Wisconsin Historical Society, Edwin Stein.
I had to give some sort of commentary for the camera while I baked. Not wanting to overthink it, I simply shared the associations that came to mind along the way.
As I whipped the egg whites into glossy peaks, I talked about how I used to make a mean lemon meringue pie. I reflected on how I had always envied my mom’s bowl-scraping skills. As a kid I was mesmerized by the way she swiftly and efficiently scraped batter from a bowl. I shared tips I had picked up from watching countless hours of competitive baking shows with my husband.
The pie turned out pretty good.

I finished listening to Seyforth’s interview on the drive home. He talked about Gulley’s impacts as an educator, including developing a curriculum for chefs at the Tuskegee Institute and training Navy chefs at the university during World War II. He explained how Gulley was prohibited from receiving promotions because of his race and often wasn’t allowed to stay the night in towns where he was invited to speak.
Questions bubbled up. Where around the state had Gulley given talks? Could he have crossed paths with my grandparents? I thought about my Japanese American grandfather, Kenneth Koji, who served in World War II and raised his family in Wisconsin. How would their experiences have been similar? How would they have been different?
At home, I followed my curiosity down a rabbit hole that took me from vintage recipes to military service codes to historical photos of the UW-Madison campus.
I realized pie wasn’t the point. It was the entry point.
I had connected to Gulley’s story through a shared love of food. But it sparked curiosity and learning about so much more.
Watch “Carson Gulley: A Recipe for Change” and see how connection and curiosity show up for you. Maybe you’ll want to know more about how the educational resource was developed. Or maybe you’ll find yourself 12 pages deep in the UW Archives website exploring historical photos campus pranks.
And if you wind up making Gulley’s bean recipe, I’d love to hear about it.
“Wisconsin Biographies” is a free multimedia classroom resource collection developed for grades 3-6. Discover more stories of Wisconsin history makers and explore the resources on the PBS Wisconsin Education website.
What do you think?
I would love to get your thoughts, suggestions, and questions in the comments below. Thanks for sharing!
Tawny Morrison